Many criminal defense attorneys focus heavily on SEO, paid ads, and referrals to grow their firm—but few take the time to optimize their intake process. That’s a mistake. Even with a strong marketing budget, poor intake procedures will cause qualified leads to go cold.
If your team doesn’t answer the phone promptly, follow a clear intake script, and close the call with confidence, you’re losing clients—and revenue—daily.
An independent study shows that law firms that answer incoming calls within the first two rings convert up to 20% more leads than those who let the phone ring longer. That 20% doesn’t just represent more clients—it translates to tens of thousands in additional revenue over a year for criminal defense attorneys.
In criminal law, where time-sensitive cases dominate, the first lawyer to connect wins the case. Below is a breakdown of actionable ways to boost your profits by improving how your law firm handles leads—especially over the phone.
Let’s be blunt: If you’re not answering every phone call, someone else is. Criminal defense clients are often dealing with an arrest, an active charge, or a police investigation. They’re scared, they need answers, and they want someone to talk to now—not hours later. The moment they dial your firm, the clock starts ticking.
The data is clear: speed equals revenue. Every minute your phone goes unanswered, you’re giving that client—and their case value—to another attorney.
Most arrests, police stops, and legal emergencies don’t happen during 9-5 office hours. If your firm only answers calls during business hours, you’re missing a large portion of potential clients.
You have two immediate options:
Make sure whoever is answering your calls:
Don’t leave your potential revenue in the hands of a voicemail box.
Even if your calls are answered quickly, what’s said next determines whether that client books or bounces. Intake staff must be friendly, calm, professional, and confident—especially since most criminal clients are under extreme stress.
Your script should be:
Role-play this script with your team until it becomes second nature. Call audits and recorded intake reviews can further improve performance.
Criminal defense leads go cold fast. But a missed call doesn’t mean a lost client—unless you don’t follow up.
Leads who don’t convert on the first call might still be comparing lawyers. Your follow-up could be the difference between signing a $5,000 case or losing it.
Even if you’ve answered the phone quickly and built rapport, the lead needs a reason to move forward now.
Use a powerful close like:
“The attorney offers a free consultation to explain your legal rights and what you should do next. The sooner we talk, the more options we have. Can I confirm 3 p.m. for you today?”
That combination of value, urgency, and direction gets people to book—and show up.
If your intake system is tight, it’s time to drive more calls to your firm. One of the most cost-effective ways to do that is Google Local Services Ads (LSAs).
When paired with strong intake, LSAs can flood your phone line with real potential clients.
While LSAs bring paid traffic, local SEO brings organic traffic—and it fuels long-term success. Use daily blogging to attract high-intent visitors who find your firm through informational content.
Each blog post should:
Searchers who find your blog and call your firm are already warmed up—and likely to convert if your intake is on point.
Because most potential clients are in urgent legal situations—arrests, court dates, or active investigations, if you don’t answer fast, another firm will.
Use a legal-focused answering service with trained intake agents. It’s more affordable than losing 10+ cases a month due to missed calls.
Use call recording and tracking software to review how your team handles calls. Look for missed opportunities, weak closings, or low empathy.
At least 3 call attempts within the first 24 hours, followed by a text and an email. Many clients just need a small nudge to respond.
Yes. Firms that improve their intake see up to 20-30% more cases signed, which translates to significant increases in monthly revenue.
Your firm may be investing heavily in marketing—but if you don’t answer the phone fast, speak with confidence, and close leads properly, you’re leaving thousands of dollars in revenue on the table every month.
FORWARD Lawyer Marketing helps criminal defense law firms optimize their intake processes, boost call conversions, and drive more qualified leads through Google LSAs and SEO.
Contact FORWARD Lawyer Marketing at (888) 590-9687 for a free consultation, and let us help your firm generate more revenue.
Download Your Copy
