Most personal injury lawyers treat Instagram like a billboard—and that’s why they get ignored. Logos, case types, firm awards, and “We fight for you” slogans don’t inspire referrals. What does? Stories. Emotions. Humanity.
Instagram isn’t where legal research happens—it’s where trust is built, and stories get shared. If you want to turn followers into referral sources, you need to shift from promotional content to narratives that make people feel something. The right post doesn’t just get a like—it makes someone think, “That sounds like what happened to my cousin. I should send this to them.”
Let’s break down what personal injury lawyers should actually post on Instagram to get more referrals—and how to do it without sounding like a commercial.
Injury law is emotional. Whether it’s a car crash, a slip and fall, or a wrongful death, the people you serve are hurting, confused, and overwhelmed. Your content should reflect that, not just the outcome.
Instead of:
“We won $300,000 for a car accident client!”
Try:
“One moment, he was driving home from work. The next, he was in a hospital bed, unsure if he’d ever walk the same again. We helped him hold the at-fault driver accountable, and now he has the resources to rebuild his life.”
What this does:
End with a soft line like:
“If someone you care about is going through something like this, let them know they don’t have to go through it alone.”
This shifts the post from promotion to compassion, exactly what triggers shares and referrals.
People don’t refer to cold logos. They refer people. One of the easiest ways to build Instagram trust is by showing the humans behind the law firm.
What to post:
These posts build an emotional connection. They also make your firm more memorable, which is key to top-of-mind referrals when someone in your audience hears, “I just got in a wreck.”
You don’t need to sound like a law professor. You just need to explain something useful in a way that feels personal and easy to share.
High-performing Instagram post ideas:
End each post with a soft call to action:
“This happens more than people realize. Feel free to share if you know someone who might need this.”
That phrasing removes pressure while inviting referrals. It also encourages followers to help someone else, which is one of the most powerful motivators for sharing.
Your Instagram feed builds credibility. But your Stories and Highlights should serve as a referral hub—bite-sized content that followers can return to when a friend asks them, “Do you know any good injury lawyers?”
Build Highlights for:
Each Highlight should include short videos or text slides that tell your firm’s story through the lens of helping, not pitching.
Example:
“We helped a mother of three who got hit by a distracted driver two blocks from her house.
Here’s what we want other families to know.”
Add a link sticker or “Message Us” CTA on the last slide.
This turns your profile into a referral-friendly, on-demand resource that followers can quickly forward to someone in need.
Many lawyers write posts aimed at the injured party, but most of your followers aren’t currently hurt. They’re friends, coworkers, and family members of people who might need help. So, your captions should be written for them.
Try saying:
By speaking to the referrer, you’re activating your audience’s social instincts, and that’s where the best leads come from.
Avoid legal jargon, dry statute quotes, and overly aggressive self-promotion. Posts like “We fight hard for YOU!” or “Call now for BIG results!” sound impersonal and outdated. Focus on stories, empathy, and clear examples of how you’ve helped real people.
Aim for 3–4 posts per week. Consistency matters more than volume. Mix formats: short videos, carousels, and story-style posts. Reuse high-performing content every few months with a fresh visual or updated caption.
Yes, but always protect privacy. Use initials or change small details unless you have written permission to share identifiable information. Clients love being acknowledged—just be respectful of their boundaries.
Use phrases like:
They help discovery but aren’t everything. Use 5–10 focused hashtags like #InjuryLawyer, #CarAccidentHelp, or #KnowYourRights. Location-based hashtags like #ChicagoLawyer or #HoustonAccidentAttorney work well too.
If you’re ready to move beyond lifeless legal posts and start creating Instagram content that earns trust, triggers emotion, and leads to real referrals, we’ve got you covered.
At FORWARD Lawyer Marketing, we help personal injury law firms create social content that feels human, helpful, and highly shareable. From story scripts and caption writing to full video production and page management, we turn your feed into your most powerful referral tool.
Contact FORWARD Lawyer Marketing at (888) 590-9687, and let’s turn your stories into new cases.
Referrals aren’t random. They’re built one story at a time. Let’s start yours.
Download Your Copy
