Many personal injury law firms lose a large percentage of potential clients simply because those visitors didn’t convert on their first visit. People who land on your website but don’t call or submit a contact form are not lost opportunities—they’re just delayed decisions. Retargeting ads offer an effective solution to bring those visitors back and turn them into actual clients. By using digital ads that follow users after they leave your site, you create multiple additional chances to capture their attention, build trust, and prompt action.
The decision to hire a personal injury lawyer is rarely made on impulse. Most people research multiple firms before making a call. Others may be unsure if they even have a valid case. Some visitors get distracted. Some may be browsing on their phone with the intention of calling later. Retargeting gives your firm another opportunity to connect with these people at a later time when they may be more ready to act.
To make retargeting work, you first need to understand user intent. Not everyone who visits your site is equally ready to commit. For example, someone who landed on a blog post about “what to do after a car accident” may be in the early stages of information gathering, whereas someone who visits your contact page and spends time there is likely further along in the decision-making process. Retargeting allows you to tailor your messaging to those different levels of readiness.
Install tracking pixels (like those from Google Ads or Facebook) on your website to collect data about user behavior. These pixels allow you to segment your audience and create ad campaigns based on how they interacted with your content. Once segmented, you can display different ads to users who read educational content, spent time on service pages, or started filling out a consultation form but didn’t finish.
The key to success here is message matching. If someone spent time on your “Slip and Fall” page, show them an ad that reinforces your track record in those cases. If someone viewed your attorney bio, retarget with a video ad that introduces your team and highlights results. This level of personalization gives people a reason to reconsider your firm over competitors.
Start by segmenting your site traffic into meaningful groups. This could include visitors who:
These segments allow you to match ad content with where the potential client is in their decision process. For example, you may want to show a testimonial ad to someone who visited your auto accident page. For someone who started a contact form but didn’t complete it, you might serve a reminder ad with messaging like: “Still need legal help after your accident? We’re ready to help.”
Next, design a creative ad that is simple, direct, and emotional. People looking for personal injury representation want to know that they will be heard and helped. Your ad text should focus on empathy, availability, and results. For example: “Injured? You only have one chance to get justice. Talk to a lawyer now.” Include your law firm’s name and visual branding, a compelling call-to-action, and ideally, a testimonial or verdict statistic that builds credibility.
Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, Google Display Network, and even YouTube allow you to run remarketing campaigns. To get started, install the appropriate tracking pixels, sync them with your ad account, and begin building your custom audiences. Make sure to test different ad copy, images, and CTA placements. Use frequency caps to avoid overwhelming users with too many impressions, which can have a negative effect.
Also, pay attention to ad timing. People who bounce from your website might be more likely to convert within 3 days of their initial visit. So, front-load your ad impressions to appear more frequently in the 24 to 72 hours following their first visit. Continue showing ads for up to 30 days, but reduce frequency as time passes. Always direct your ads to landing pages that match the message in the ad to keep the experience consistent.
One mid-sized personal injury law firm based in Phoenix was seeing good traffic from their Google Ads campaigns but noticed a large bounce rate and low conversion rate. While over 1,500 people were visiting their auto accident page monthly, fewer than 3% were submitting a contact form or calling the firm. After installing Facebook and Google retargeting pixels, they launched a 30-day retargeting campaign targeting all users who spent more than 45 seconds on any practice area page but did not submit a lead form.
The ads featured video testimonials from real clients and offered a free case evaluation. Messaging was emotionally direct: “Not sure if you have a case? Our clients weren’t either. See what happened when they called us.”
After running the campaign for three months, the law firm saw a 38% increase in conversion rate among retargeted users. More importantly, retargeted visitors accounted for 26% of all new consultations during that quarter. The cost-per-lead dropped significantly compared to cold Google Ads traffic. The ads effectively warmed up undecided users and brought them back to a point where they were ready to move forward.
This campaign worked because it respected user intent, offered value, and stayed present in the decision-making window. It didn’t pressure or over-sell. It reminded. It built trust. And it delivered results.
Retargeting is a digital advertising strategy that allows you to show ads to people who have previously visited your website. It helps personal injury law firms stay visible to potential clients who left without converting, giving them another chance to contact your firm.
To set up retargeting, install tracking pixels from platforms like Facebook or Google Ads on your website. Then, create custom audience segments based on user behavior. Design specific ads for each segment and link them to relevant landing pages.
Facebook, Instagram, Google Display Network, and YouTube are the top platforms. Each allows you to retarget visitors with visual, video, or text-based ads. Facebook is particularly strong for testimonials and emotional appeals, while Google Display excels in wide reach.
Ideally, run retargeting campaigns for up to 30 days after a visitor’s first interaction. Focus ad impressions during the first 3 to 7 days for the highest chance of conversion. Use frequency caps to prevent fatigue.
Retargeting works best with consistent traffic. If your site only sees a few hundred visitors per month, your audience pool may be too small. In that case, start with paid search or SEO to increase traffic first, then layer on retargeting.
Your website visitors already showed interest—don’t let them disappear. FORWARD Lawyer Marketing builds retargeting strategies designed to bring personal injury prospects back and convert them into real consultations. We help law firms install the right tracking, build effective ad creatives, segment their audience, and optimize for results.
Contact FORWARD Lawyer Marketing at (888) 590-9687 for your free consultation, and learn how FORWARD Lawyer Marketing can help your firm stop losing leads and start winning more cases with smart, conversion-driven remarketing campaigns.
Download Your Copy
