Legal directories used to be gold mines. Back when Google wasn’t as smart, and clients didn’t know where else to look, a top listing on Avvo or FindLaw meant your phone would ring all day. But today? Most directories are cluttered, pay-to-play, and buried beneath AI answers and law firm SEO content.
So the question many DUI defense attorneys are asking is: Can I still get good leads from legal directories?
The answer is yes, but only if you do this first.
Before you rely on any directory, your firm must put in place the foundation that makes directory traffic convert. Without it, your listing is just another profile among hundreds. With it, that same listing can become a lead-generating asset that pays for itself every month.
Let’s be blunt: if your directory listing doesn’t have recent, 5-star reviews, it’s almost worthless. Legal consumers, especially those dealing with something as personal and embarrassing as a DUI, look for emotional safety first.
They’re asking:
If your Avvo, Justia, or Yelp profile shows three reviews from 2018, you’re not building trust. You’re raising doubts. That’s why step one is building a steady stream of review activity across every platform you appear on.
Here’s how to do it right:
Remember, it’s not the volume of reviews—it’s the recency and relevance that matter most. A single review from last week that says, “They walked me through every step of my DUI case and got it dismissed,” is more powerful than 20 vague five-star ratings from years ago.
Directories don’t just show up in Google because they’re old and popular. They show up because they’re part of your citation ecosystem—a network of consistent listings that confirms your law firm’s name, address, phone number, and practice area to search engines.
Before you bank on directories to drive leads, you need to audit and correct your NAP (Name, Address, Phone) data everywhere:
Why this matters:
If you skip this step, your lead funnel will leak at the foundation, and you’ll blame the directory when it’s really a data problem.
Too many lawyers treat their directory profile like a resume. Long, formal bios filled with court admissions and bar memberships. That’s fine for compliance, but terrible for conversion.
If you want your directory listing to generate real DUI leads, you need to optimize it like a landing page.
Here’s what that looks like:
If your listing reads like a lawyer wrote it for other lawyers, it won’t convert. Write for the scared, confused person who just got pulled over last night and is now scrolling legal profiles at 2:00 a.m.
A major mistake DUI attorneys make is assuming their listings aren’t working, when in reality, they have no way to track what is.
Here’s how to fix that:
This data tells you where to double down. If FindLaw sends you seven actual leads a month and AVVO sends you none, you’ll know what to cut.
Don’t rely on your gut—rely on your data.
Here’s something most attorneys haven’t realized yet: your directory content can show up inside Google’s AI-generated answers.
Google’s AI Overviews pull from sources it trusts—and high-authority legal directories are part of that pool. That means your Avvo profile could be cited as the answer to “What happens if I refuse a breathalyzer in Illinois?”
But this only happens if:
This is where directory optimization becomes SEO fuel. Every optimized profile becomes a second home for your content—a place where Google (and clients) can discover you without you ever running an ad.
Yes—but only if your listings are active, accurate, reviewed often, and designed to convert. The days of set-it-and-forget-it profiles are over. Today’s directory traffic only turns into clients when paired with strong reviews, messaging, and tracking.
Avvo, Justia, Yelp, and your local bar association directories tend to drive the most visibility for DUI cases. Super Lawyers and Martindale can help with credibility, but usually offer less traffic unless heavily invested in it.
Set up call tracking and email lead capture. Compare lead quality and volume over 90 days. If the leads are real, relevant, and reasonably priced, continue. If not, cancel and invest in owned media (website, SEO, Google Business).
A clear headline, emotional client-focused messaging, strong reviews, and an easy way to contact you, combined with consistent citation data and a recent photo. People want to see someone they can trust, not read a resume.
No. Directories should support your marketing, not replace it. They’re great for validation and discovery, but the smartest DUI firms pair them with SEO, reviews, social content, and AI-ready blog writing to control their brand narrative.
If your legal directory profiles aren’t sending you real DUI leads, it’s not the platform—it’s the setup. At FORWARD Lawyer Marketing, we help DUI lawyers optimize every listing, track every lead, and rewrite every profile for one purpose: conversion.
We’ll audit your entire directory presence, correct your citations, rewrite your messaging, and build a system that turns traffic into paying clients.
Contact FORWARD Lawyer Marketing at (888) 590-9687, and we’ll show you exactly how to turn outdated listings into a DUI lead funnel that works around the clock.
Stop hoping your profile is doing the job. Let’s make sure it actually is.
Download Your Copy
